Guide for patients & caregivers

Ankle Pain With a Normal X-Ray: What Else Could It Be?

Ankle pain with a normal X-ray? Learn how sprains, ligament and tendon injuries and cartilage lesions can hide, red flags, when MRI follows and what to ask.

By SameCase EditorialUpdated 6 min read

Prepared with AI assistance and checked against the cited sources. No independent clinician review has been completed. How we prepare articles

Why does my ankle still hurt if the X-ray is normal?

Ankle pain with a normal X-ray is common because an X-ray mainly checks for broken bones. Sprains, which are ligament injuries, along with tendon problems and some cartilage injuries, do not show clearly on a plain X-ray. So the result usually rules out an obvious fracture, but not every cause of pain.

This guide is for adults whose ankle X-ray was reported as normal, either after an injury or for pain that has gone on for a while. It explains what the X-ray can and cannot show and what to discuss next. It cannot diagnose the cause of your pain.

Symptoms that need urgent care

The NHS advises calling emergency services or going to an emergency department after an injury if you heard a crack, the ankle has changed shape or points at an odd angle, the foot is numb or tingling, or the skin has turned blue or grey or is cold to touch. Do not drive yourself.

Get urgent advice the same day (NHS 111 in the UK) if any of the following apply, even if an earlier X-ray was normal.

  • Severe pain, or pain that is getting worse.
  • Swelling or bruising that is large or increasing.
  • Being unable to put weight on the leg or walk more than a few steps.
  • Feeling faint, dizzy or sick from the pain.
  • A very high temperature, or feeling hot, cold or shivery, which could be an infection.

What does a normal ankle X-ray rule out?

An ankle X-ray shows the bones of the lower leg and ankle, and whether a visible fracture or dislocation is present. Healthdirect Australia notes that an X-ray may be used to rule out broken bones when a sprain is suspected.

OrthoInfo, the patient site of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, explains that X-rays do not show damage to ligaments, cartilage or tendons. It also notes that severe sprains can cause pain, bruising and swelling similar to a fracture, which is why an X-ray is sometimes taken. Stress X-rays, taken while the ankle is gently pushed in different directions, can help show whether injured ligaments have made the joint unstable.

Is it a sprained ankle?

Most ankle injuries with a normal X-ray are sprains. OrthoInfo says a sprain is mainly diagnosed from how the injury happened, your symptoms and the examination. Sprains are graded from 1 to 3: stretching with tiny tears, a partial tear, or a complete tear of the ligament.

Nearly all isolated low ankle sprains are treated without surgery. Healthdirect says most take 4 to 6 weeks to heal, though some people feel discomfort for up to 12 months. Physiotherapy with balance and strengthening exercises helps recovery. The NHS advises avoiding strenuous exercise such as running for up to 8 weeks, as there is a risk of further damage.

If a sprain does not heal well, the ankle can feel weak and keep giving way, known as chronic ankle instability. Repeated sprains can lead to long-term pain and arthritis, so rehabilitation matters. Our ankle ligament tear guide explains how MRI and ultrasound describe ligament damage.

Could it be a tendon or nerve problem?

Cleveland Clinic lists tendinitis, including peroneal tendinitis on the outer ankle and Achilles tendinitis at the back, among common causes of ankle pain, along with bursitis, sinus tarsi syndrome and nerve problems such as tarsal tunnel syndrome. The NHS links pain in the ankle and heel, with calf pain when standing on tiptoes, to Achilles tendonitis.

The NHS advises getting urgent advice if you heard a snap, grinding or popping noise at the time of injury or cannot walk. Cleveland Clinic includes Achilles tendon rupture among the injuries that cause ankle pain, so sudden pain at the back of the ankle after a push-off or jump should be checked promptly. Ankle pain without an injury can also come from arthritis, including rheumatoid arthritis, or from infection, according to Cleveland Clinic. Tell your clinician about other swollen joints, fever or a history of inflammatory conditions.

Could a cartilage injury (osteochondral lesion) be the cause?

An osteochondral lesion of the talus is damage to the cartilage and the bone beneath it on the top of the talus, the lower bone of the ankle joint. A CC BY review in The Open Orthopaedics Journal describes it as commonly linked to ankle injury, including single or repeated sprains. Symptoms are nonspecific: pain, swelling, stiffness and sometimes locking or catching.

The same review notes that X-rays are usually the first test but have low sensitivity, and one study it cites found 41% of these lesions were missed on X-ray. MRI is often considered the most appropriate test after X-rays, and CT can show the bone in more detail. Conservative treatment is usually tried first for small, stable lesions; surgery may be discussed in other cases. Our osteochondral defect MRI guide explains stable and unstable wording.

When does an MRI follow a normal ankle X-ray?

OrthoInfo says an MRI is not required to diagnose an ankle sprain, but may be ordered to look at ligaments, cartilage and tendons, if there are signs of a high ankle sprain affecting the ligaments that join the two lower leg bones, or if symptoms continue beyond 6 to 8 weeks despite treatment.

A stress fracture is another possibility when pain builds up gradually with activity rather than after a twist. OrthoInfo notes that stress fractures of the fibula or talus may not show on early X-rays, while MRI or a bone scan can detect them sooner. Our stress fracture MRI guide covers that report wording.

Questions to ask your clinician

Bring the X-ray report and a note of how the pain started, where it sits and whether the ankle gives way, locks or catches. These questions may help.

  • Which injuries does my normal X-ray rule out, and which can it not show?
  • What grade of sprain do you think this is, and how long should recovery take?
  • Does my examination suggest a high ankle sprain, a tendon injury or instability?
  • At what point would an MRI or stress X-ray change my treatment?
  • Would physiotherapy or a brace help, and when can I return to sport?
  • Which symptoms should make me come back sooner?

Comparing similar cases on SameCase

On SameCase, patients and verified doctors share de-identified cases. Reading how others with ankle pain and a normal X-ray described their injury, how long recovery took and when scans followed can help you prepare clearer questions. Similar cases cannot diagnose your ankle or tell you whether you need an MRI; that decision stays with your own clinician.

Sources and further reading

For patients & caregivers

Share your case and learn from others

Learn from doctors and other people's cases to find a way forward with your health problem. New cases are public immediately. Don't add names or identifying details.

Keep learning