Guide for patients & caregivers
Hammer Toe, Claw Toe or Mallet Toe: What Causes Them and What Helps?
Hammer toe, claw toe and mallet toe explained: which joint bends, common causes, footwear and self-care, when diabetes needs a podiatrist, and surgery.
Prepared with AI assistance and checked against the cited sources. No independent clinician review has been completed. How we prepare articles
What is a hammer toe, and what are the symptoms?
A hammer toe is a toe that stays bent at its middle joint, so the toe curls up in the middle and the tip points down. Cleveland Clinic describes hammertoes as one of the most common foot problems. They usually affect the smaller toes rather than the big toe.
Early on, the toe is often flexible and can still be straightened. Over time, tight muscles and tendons can fix the toe in its bent shape, and a rigid toe is harder to treat without surgery.
The bent toe is usually visible. Other symptoms described by Cleveland Clinic include pain on top of the toe or in the ball of the foot, difficulty moving or straightening the toe, corns, calluses or blisters where the toe rubs on the shoe, and swelling or skin discolouration. Untreated, a toe can become fixed in position and affect walking or balance.
A podiatrist usually diagnoses the problem by examining your foot, moving the toes and watching you stand or walk. A foot X-ray may be taken to look at the bones. If nerve or muscle problems are suspected, other tests may be suggested.
This guide is general education. A GP, podiatrist or foot surgeon needs to examine your foot to say what type of toe problem you have and what will help.
Signs that need prompt or urgent care
Cleveland Clinic advises seeing a provider right away if you lose feeling in your toes or develop sores or wounds on the tips or tops of your toes. NIDDK, part of the US National Institutes of Health, advises people with diabetes to call their health care provider right away if they notice:
- a cut, blister or bruise on the foot that does not start to heal after a few days
- red, warm or painful skin, which can be a sign of infection
- a callus with dried blood inside it, which can be the first sign of a wound underneath
- a foot infection that becomes black and smelly, which may be a sign of gangrene
When should you see a GP or podiatrist?
The NHS toe pain page advises seeing a GP if toe pain is stopping you doing normal activities, is getting worse or keeps coming back, has not improved after 2 weeks of home treatment, or if you have diabetes and foot pain, because foot problems can be more serious with diabetes. The NHS says you might be able to refer yourself directly to a podiatrist without seeing a GP; your GP surgery can tell you what is available locally. Outside the UK, ask your local doctor or podiatry service.
Diabetes can damage the nerves in the feet and reduce blood flow, so injuries may not be felt and can turn into ulcers, as Healthdirect explains. NIDDK notes that with nerve damage, corns and calluses can become ulcers, which is one reason a bent toe that rubs is worth getting checked. NIDDK suggests checking your feet every day, including between the toes, and having a foot check at every health care visit.
Hammer toe vs claw toe vs mallet toe
The small toes each have three joints. Cleveland Clinic separates the three conditions by which joints are bent:
- Hammer toe: a bend in the middle joint of the toe.
- Mallet toe: a bend in the end joint, nearest the toenail, so the tip points down. It most often affects the second toe.
- Claw toe: bends in both the middle and end joints, so the toe curls like a claw and may press into the shoe or floor.
What causes hammer toes and claw toes?
Hammer toes develop when something pushes the toes out of position for a long time, and the muscles and tendons tighten to match. Causes and risk factors Cleveland Clinic describes include:
- shoes that are too narrow, too tight or too short, and high heels
- high-arched or flat feet, or toes that are naturally long
- bunions pushing the toes out of line
- arthritis, including rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis
- nerve damage, for example from diabetes, an injury or some neurological conditions, which is a particular cause of claw toes
- stroke, previous foot injury or surgery, and a family history of claw toes
Footwear and self-care that can help
Treatment aims to take pressure off the toes. Cleveland Clinic lists shoes with a wide, deep toe box, toe pads and taping, shoe inserts (orthotics) or toe spacers, and toe stretches and exercises. For claw toes it also suggests shoes with a closed back or heel strap so you do not grip with your toes. When choosing shoes, it suggests avoiding narrow, pointed styles and trying shoes on later in the day, when feet are slightly larger.
For sore toes generally, the NHS suggests resting and raising the foot, wearing wide comfortable shoes with a low heel and soft sole, avoiding high heels and tight pointy shoes, and gentle stretching. A pharmacist can advise on pain relief and on insoles and pads for your shoes. NIDDK says people with diabetes and hammertoes may need extra-wide or deep shoes and should not cut corns or use corn plasters or liquid corn removers.
Cleveland Clinic says most hammertoes respond to these treatments, but improvement can take several weeks. Tell your podiatrist if your toes are getting worse or not improving.
When is surgery considered, and what does it involve?
Surgery is usually considered when other treatments have not relieved symptoms or walking is very painful, and is more likely for rigid toes. Depending on the toe and its cause, Cleveland Clinic describes procedures that release or lengthen a tight tendon, move a tendon to the top of the toe, reshape bone, or fuse a joint so the toe stays straight (arthrodesis). A pin or wire may hold the toe in place while it heals.
Your surgeon will explain which operation fits your foot, the recovery time and the risks, including how diabetes, smoking or circulation problems affect healing. Ask about this before deciding. If any medicines or injections are suggested for pain or swelling, discuss them with your clinician or pharmacist, and do not stop or change a prescribed medicine without talking to the prescriber.
Questions to ask your GP, podiatrist or surgeon
These questions can help at a GP, podiatry or surgical appointment:
- Is this a hammer, claw or mallet toe, and is it still flexible or rigid?
- What is causing it, and does it need any tests, such as an X-ray or a nerve check?
- Which shoes, pads or insoles would suit my foot?
- Is a bunion or arthritis contributing?
- With my diabetes or circulation, how often should my feet be checked?
- When would you suggest surgery, and what would recovery involve?
How comparing similar cases on SameCase can help you prepare
On SameCase, patients and verified doctors share de-identified cases. Reading how others described similar toes, footwear changes or surgery can help you decide what to ask. It cannot diagnose your foot or predict your result.
Sources and further reading
For patients & caregivers
Share your case and learn from others
Learn from doctors and other people's cases to find a way forward with your health problem. New cases are public immediately. Don't add names or identifying details.