Guide for patients & caregivers

Lung-RADS 3 on a Screening CT: What Does Probably Benign Mean?

Lung-RADS 3 on a screening CT means a probably benign finding checked with a 6-month scan. Learn what the score means, red flags and questions to ask.

By SameCase EditorialUpdated 6 min read

Prepared with AI assistance and checked against the cited sources. No independent clinician review has been completed. How we prepare articles

What does Lung-RADS 3 mean on a screening CT?

Lung-RADS 3 means your low-dose lung screening CT showed a nodule or finding that is probably benign, but that the radiologist wants to look at again to be sure. The usual recommendation is a repeat low-dose CT in about 6 months to check whether it has changed.

Lung-RADS 3 counts as a 'positive' screen. That word can sound alarming, but here it means 'needs closer follow-up', not 'cancer found'. This guide explains the score in general terms. It cannot interpret your scan, and your care team decides your plan.

Symptoms that need checking sooner

Do not wait for the 6-month scan if you develop new symptoms. NHS guidance advises seeing a doctor if you have a cough lasting more than 3 weeks or other possible lung cancer symptoms, and asking for an urgent appointment if you cough up blood or notice blood on a tissue you have coughed into.

The NHS says to call emergency services or go to an emergency department if you are struggling to breathe, choking, gasping and unable to speak, or if you have pain in your chest or upper back. Use your local emergency number outside the UK.

  • A cough that lasts more than 3 weeks, or a long-standing cough that changes
  • Coughing up blood
  • Increasing breathlessness, or chest infections that keep returning or do not get better
  • Weight loss without trying, loss of appetite or constant tiredness

Why is Lung-RADS 3 called probably benign?

Lung-RADS (Lung CT Screening Reporting and Data System) is the American College of Radiology's scoring system for lung screening CT. In published summaries of the system, category 3 is labelled 'probably benign', with a stated cancer risk of about 1% to 2%. Put another way, the large majority of findings in this group turn out not to be cancer.

That figure describes groups of people, not you. It is an average for everyone placed in the category, and it cannot tell you what your own nodule is. Your team weighs your nodule's features, your history and any earlier scans.

Lung nodules are very common. Cleveland Clinic notes that radiologists see them in nearly 1 in 3 chest CT scans, and that most are caused by things such as old infection, inflammation or scarring.

What kinds of findings are placed in category 3?

The category depends mainly on the type of nodule (solid, part-solid or ground-glass), its size, and whether it is new or has been seen before. Examples discussed in a published review of Lung-RADS version 2022 include a part-solid nodule with only a small solid part, which is usually rechecked at 6 months, and a category 4A nodule that has stayed stable on follow-up, which can be moved down to category 3.

Findings that look like a recent infection are handled differently in the 2022 version: they are often placed in category 0 with a short repeat scan instead. If your report says '3S', the 'S' means the radiologist also saw something important that is not related to lung cancer, such as a finding in the heart or large blood vessels, which your doctor will discuss separately.

For findings in this category, Lung-RADS management recommends follow-up imaging at 6 months rather than immediate tests. Watching a nodule over time is one of the most useful ways to judge it: benign nodules usually stay the same size or even fade, while a change in size or texture prompts a closer look.

A short-interval scan also avoids sending many people with harmless findings for invasive procedures. NCI notes that false-positive screening results can cause anxiety and lead to further tests, such as biopsy, which carry their own risks.

What happens after the 6-month follow-up scan?

Under Lung-RADS version 2022, a category 3 finding that is stable or smaller at the follow-up scan usually moves to category 2, and you return to annual screening. If the finding has grown or developed new features, the radiologist assigns a new category, which may lead to closer follow-up or other tests such as a PET-CT.

Some findings that lead to category 3 are thought to be infection or inflammation and may shrink or disappear by the next scan. Your report or your clinician can tell you which kind of finding yours is.

Waiting for a follow-up scan can be stressful. It may help to ask your team how and when results will be shared, and who to contact with questions in the meantime.

Why the 6-month scan is easy to miss

Research suggests that follow-up after Lung-RADS 3 is often late or missed. In one US study across several screening sites, only about 3 in 10 people with a Lung-RADS 3 result had their follow-up scan within the recommended 6 months, although more had it later. Another study found that when results letters described a Lung-RADS 3 finding as 'benign', people were less likely to complete the recommended follow-up.

'Probably benign' is reassuring, but it still means the scan needs repeating. Check who books the 6-month scan, ask for the date in writing, and contact the screening service if you have not heard by the time it is due.

Questions to ask your clinician

Writing questions down can help you get clear answers:

  • What finding led to category 3, and how big is it?
  • Was it compared with an earlier scan?
  • Could this be infection or inflammation that may settle?
  • Exactly when is the 6-month scan, and who will book it?
  • What would happen if the nodule is stable, and what if it has changed?
  • Are there other findings on the report, such as emphysema, that need separate follow-up?
  • Which symptoms should make me contact you before the next scan?

How comparing similar cases on SameCase can help

On SameCase, patients and verified doctors share de-identified cases. Seeing how others with a Lung-RADS 3 result organised their 6-month scan, or which questions they asked about nodule size and earlier scans, can help you prepare for your own appointment.

Similar cases cannot predict what your follow-up scan will show. Your radiologist and care team, who can see your images and history, make the decisions about your care.

Sources and further reading

For patients & caregivers

Share your case and learn from others

Learn from doctors and other people's cases to find a way forward with your health problem. New cases are public immediately. Don't add names or identifying details.

Keep learning